George Washington, Namesake of our Round Table

Nov 2019


Greetings. We are taking our winter break. Our next meeting will be on Wednesday, March 4, at the Mount Vernon Inn starting at 6 p.m.

Here are some upcoming local events of interest:

November 14, 2019, 7:30 p.m.:  Gadsby’s Tavern Museum, Alexandria, Virginia:  George Washington’s Tomb
Join Matthew Costello, Senior Historian of the White House Historical Society, as he shares from his new book The Property of the Nation: George Washington’s Tomb, Mount Vernon, and the Memory of the First President. He traces the shift of America’s attention from the official days of commemoration around Washington’s death to spontaneous visits by citizens through the story of his tomb. This history reflects the building of a memory of America’s first president—of, by, and for the American people. Book signing after lecture.

November 15, 12:30 p.m.:  American Revolution Institute (Society of the Cincinnati), Anderson House:  A Pensioner of the Revolution
Join Deputy Director and Curator Emily Schulz Parsons for a discussion of the oil portrait A Pensioner of the Revolution, painted in 1830 by John Neagle (1796-1865), and its role in the struggle for federal pensions for Revolutionary War veterans. This somber and arresting view of a poor, elderly man hints at the financial struggles many soldiers of the Revolution faced after the war. According to the artist, the portrait depicts Joseph Winter, a German-born veteran who was living on the streets of Philadelphia when Neagle met him. Moved by the story of this “lone wanderer in a world evincing but little feeling or sympathy for him,” Neagle painted Winter’s portrait and arranged for it to be published as a mezzotint, in the hopes that it would bring attention to the need for comprehensive pension legislation for the men who fought for American freedom.  The presentation will last approximately 30 minutes with time afterwards for up-close viewing of the painting, which is featured in the exhibition America’s First Veterans.

November 19, 6:30 p.m.:  Society of Naval Architects (SNAME):  Larrie D. Ferreiro on How Naval Architecture Saved the American Revolution
Larrie D. Ferreiro, PhD, will present a talk at the Society of Naval Architects (SNAME), Hampton Roads section, titled “How Naval Architecture Saved the American Revolution.”  For more information, click on this link:  https://www.sname.org/hamptonroadssection/home  This program will be held at the Hampton Yacht Club, 4707 Victoria Blvd, Hampton, Virginia.  Non-SNAME members can attend. Contact: David Laurence Hansch by email at dhansch@vt.edu.

December 5, 7 p.m.:  The Fred W. Smith National Library at Mount Vernon:  Life of John Andre: The Redcoat Who Turned Benedict Arnold
Mount Vernon welcomes you to a lecture by author D.A.B. Ronald to discuss his book, John Andre: The Redcoat Who Turned Benedict Arnold.  Cost is: free.  For more information, click on this link:  https://www.mountvernon.org/library/library-events-programs/ford-evening-book-talks/ford-evening-book-talk-dab-ronald

March 20 (6:30 p.m.) to March 22 (noon), 2020:  America’s History, LLC presents its 9th Annual Conference on the American Revolution
Williamsburg, Virginia America’s History, LLC presents its 9th Annual Conference on the American Revolution.  This year’s lineup of presenters include:

Edward G. Lengel, Head of Faculty — ” Some Desperate Glory: The Battles of Connecticut Farms and Springfield, June 1780
Stephen Brumwell —“Turncoat: Benedict Arnold and the Crisis of American Liberty”
Michael Gabriel —“To Induce the Officers & Soldiery to Exert Themselves’: Plunder and Trophies in the Revolutionary War.” 
T. Cole Jones —“Captives of Liberty: British, German and Loyalist Prisoners of War and the Politics of Vengeance”
Larry Kidder —“Ten Crucial Days: Washington’s Campaign against Trenton and Princeton”
Mark Edward Lender —“Cabal!: The Plot against George Washington”
James Kirby Martin —“The American Revolution: For Some of the People or All of the People”
Nathaniel Philbrick —“In the Hurricane’s Eye: The Genius of George Washington, the Battle of the Capes and the Victory at Yorktown”
Eric Schnitzer —“The Value of Revisionism: Don Troiani’s Campaign to Saratoga – 1777″
Gary Sellick, Emerging Scholar —“Black Men, Red Coats: The Creation of the Carolina Corps in Revolutionary South Carolina”

Join your colleagues at a Fifes & Drum Cocktail Reception on Friday evening for Speakers and Attendees.  Hear a Revolutionary War sites preservation update from the American Battlefield Trust. Conference Registration: includes cocktail reception, lunch and refreshment breaks:  $250, if paid by 2/1/20; and after 2/1/20 registration is $280.  Exclusive Offer: Discounted tickets to the Colonial Williamsburg Historic Area will be available to all attendees to use before or after the conference. Conference Hotel: We have booked a block of rooms at the Colonial Williamsburg’s Woodlands Hotel next to the Colonial Williamsburg Visitor’s Center at a rate of $92.00 per night (double or single occupancy) or suite $112. This hotel provides a hot and cold breakfast buffet each day.  Their 2016, 2017, 2018 and 2019 Conferences sold out, so please register early to avoid disappointment. For more information about the 9th Annual Conference on the American Revolution and the bus tour on the Friday of “Southside Revolutionary Virginia 1775 Tour,” or to register, please go online at http://americashistoryllc.com/2019/9th-annual-conference-of-the-american-revolution-march-20-22-2020-3/ or call America’s History at (703) 785-4373.


McBurney Recommendation:  New London Merchant Nathaniel Shaw is Brazen about Evading British Duties

In 1769, Captain William Reid of the Royal Navy sloop Liberty was prowling about the southern New England coast for suspected smugglers who sought to avoid paying British duties on imports. On July 17, Liberty seized two vessels from Connecticut, Sally and Thames, and carried them into Newport, Rhode Island.  According to Michael R. Derderian, in an article in the Journal of the American Revolution (https://allthingsliberty.com/2017/10/licentious-republic-maritime-skirmishes-narragansett-bay-1763-1769/), “The captain from one of the captured vessels had an altercation with Captain Reid over the return of some personal possessions. After he retook his possessions forcefully, the men of the Liberty open fired with a volley of muskets as the captain, with his retrieved possessions, escaped to shore. The citizens of Newport witnessed the events unfolding and became enraged by the actions of the Royal Navy. Later that evening Captain Reid and most of his crew went ashore to convene with Rhode Island governor William Wanton to answer for their conduct. Meanwhile, a group of citizens stormed the Liberty and dumped the vessel’s armaments into the harbor while cutting the mooring lines and riggings, thus rendering the ship inoperable. As the Liberty drifted towards Goat Island, it was set ablaze and destroyed. Captain Reid appealed to local authorities to apprehend and punish the individuals responsible for destroying the Liberty. In typical Rhode Island government fashion, they did practically nothing to find the culprits. Governor Wanton, although a loyalist, issued a proclamation and offered a reward to find those responsible, but no one came forward with any information.”  This ship burning is considered in some circles one of the first violent patriotic protests leading to the American Revolution.

The day after the burning of Liberty, with no armed vessel to stop them, a Newport mob released one of the seized vessels, the Sally.  The captain of the other seized vessel, Thames, successfully demanded that his vessel be released for lack of evidence.

Nathaniel Shaw, a prominent New London merchant who bought rum and molasses from French and Spanish islands in the Caribbean and resold them in the thirteen colonies, was in Newport when Liberty was destroyed.  Shaw was the owner of the Thames.  Indeed, Captain Reid later stated that prior to the burning of his vessel, Shaw had threatened him unless Reid freed two French sailors still on board the Thames.  It is not saying too much to suggest that Shaw likely played a prominent role in  persuading the mob of Newport sailors to destroy the Liberty.

J. L. Bell, in his superb website on revolutionary Boston, delves into the burning of Liberty. Interestingly, he quotes from several letters written by Nathaniel Shaw to his ship captains and agents, ordering them to pay as little in British duties as possible. For example, on July 13, 1774, Shaw wrote to his agent in New York City, “The bearer [Capn?] Tinker has on board about twenty thousand Gal Melasses in the Brig Mermaid wich you must dispose off on the best terms you can for my Interest. We have reported 150 hhd & 50 Teirces. I beg you will Cheat them much as you can of ye Duties.”  (Bold added).  It is rare to find such a brazen written statement of the intent to evade British duties on imported goods, but here it is!

Bell writes, “Shaw and Tinker had reported 15,000 gallons in hogsheads and another 3,300 in the smaller casks called tierces, or about 10% short of what they actually had brought in. So any way that [Shaw’s agent] could ‘Cheat’ on the duties was added profit.  Given Shaw’s normal way of doing business, Capt. William Reid probably had good reason to be suspicious when he saw two of the merchant’s ships rendezvousing in Long Island Sound on 17 July 1769. Once Reid had seized those ships, Shaw came roaring into Newport to get them back.”

You can sign up for J. L. Bell’s “Boston 1775” daily alert at http://boston1775.blogspot.com